PDA

View Full Version : Door opens for A's in Santa Clara


Bear
01-14-2009, 06:19 PM
By Barry M. Bloom
MLB.com
01/14/09

Owner Wolff remains focused on building ballpark in Fremont

PARADISE VALLEY, Ariz. -- Commissioner Bud Selig sent Oakland A's owner Lew Wolff a letter last month stating that if his deal to build a new ballpark in Fremont, Calif., falls through, the club now has the right to "discuss a ballpark with other communities."

The letter seems to indicate that Wolff can then speak with officials from neighboring Santa Clara County, which has been considered within the territory of the San Francisco Giants. Until now, the Giants have successfully blocked a move into that area, which is just across the line from Alameda County.

Thus, if the A's want to move into Santa Clara County, it would be a decision made by the Commissioner and not by the Giants, who were ceded the rights to Santa Clara County during a ballpark vote there about 20 years ago. The vote failed, but the Giants have maintained those territorial rights ever since.

"What we've done, I think, is open up a door for the A's that's been closed," said Wolff on Wednesday, the first day of this week's two days of owners' meetings here. "My priority really is Fremont. Other communities are all over us now because of this letter, but I'm not listening to them yet. I don't want to start this process all over again."

Wolff said he will know by June whether Fremont will be home to what has been dubbed CISCO Field, because of the private partnership between the A's and CISCO Systems Inc., a leading technology company.

Though a long-awaited environmental impact report has finally come back with no major revisions, Wolff said there's opposition in the community to the project and that the Fremont City Council hasn't approved the deal, which is being paid for almost entirely with private funds.

"We're literally going door-to-door talking to people," Wolff said. "They think we're going to bring gangs into the community."

More than two years ago, CISCO and the A's agreed to purchase the property and build the ballpark. The A's even paid for the environmental impact report.

"This is one of my big pet peeves," Wolff said. "We should have been under construction a year ago, but we're still trying to get approved and we're not asking for any public money. Zero. The process has become the end product. People live off the process. We're a self-stimulus program. We could have generated hundreds of union jobs already."

In the letter, dated Dec. 3, Selig reiterated his support for the Fremont project and again stated that the A's cannot continue playing in the Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum, which has been their home since they moved west from Kansas City in 1968.

"I cannot stress enough that the need for the A's to have a viable and modern stadium is a paramount objective for your organization and the game overall," Selig wrote. "The A's currently operate in one of the least desirable venues in Major League Baseball and it has placed your club in a serious disadvantage with respect to other clubs in the game."

Except for the period of 1982 to 1994, when the National Football League's Raiders were in Los Angeles, the A's have shared the facility with the football team, which returned from Los Angeles to Oakland when the stadium was expanded to accommodate football.

The A's have been trying to get out almost ever since, and several years ago ended talks with Oakland officials to build on the Coliseum parking lot when they went nowhere.

Wolff, a fraternity brother of Selig when the two went to the University of Wisconsin, was part of a group that purchased the A's on April 1, 2005. A real estate developer by trade, Wolff announced his intentions to build the new ballpark a year later with the hope of opening the 2011 season in Fremont, a city with a population of 211,662 about 20 miles south of Oakland.

Fremont is the fourth-most densely populated community in the San Francisco Bay Area, behind San Jose, San Francisco and Oakland.

While Selig said he hoped that the long struggles with Fremont would reach fruition for the A's "in the next few months," he also gave Wolff a potential Plan B.

"It is important that we get some resolution in the near future," Selig wrote. "As a result, I've decided that in the event that you are not able to promptly assure the implementation of the desired ballpark in Fremont, you may begin to discuss a ballpark with other communities. The time has come for the A's to have their own new ballpark."


This could hurt the Giants BIG time. It smells like this might be the pay back for the Bonds problem by MLB. :eek:

McCovey
01-15-2009, 09:57 AM
The A's won't move to Santa Clara. They can't because MLB has declared Santa Clara County as being part of the Giants territorial rights. And the Giants are not likely to cede their territorial rights.


Giants won't cede territorial rights
03/01/2004 10:44 PM ETBy Barry M. Bloom / MLB.com

SCOTTSDALE, Ariz. -- Peter Magowan, the Giants president and managing general partner, said on Monday that he still isn't inclined to relinquish any of his territorial rights so a new ballpark can be built to house the Oakland A's in Santa Clara County just south of San Francisco. "There are plenty of places to put (a new ballpark for the A's) that are not in the Giants territory," Magowan said. "Good places. That's where I'd like to see them concentrate, but I don't run the A's."

Magowan's comments came while he was seated in the Giants dugout at Scottsdale Stadium during his first session of the spring with reporters. The A's, who reside in the East Bay, have made motions before at trying to relocate to Santa Clara County, but were rebuffed by the Giants.

"Everybody knows what territorial rights you have when you buy a team," Magowan said. "We certainly knew in 1992 what rights we had. The A's knew what rights they had. We've stated very consistently that we will do everything within our power to enforce our rights because they have a lot of value. We might not have bought the franchise without those rights and the Commissioner has gone on the record as being fully supportive of us."
It took 20 years through two ownerships and four losing elections to finally give birth to San Francisco's SBC Park, which opened in 2000 and was built mostly on private funds, a great portion of it borrowed by the Giants. One of the losing elections was in Santa Clara County.

Before that election during the late 1980s, MLB granted the Giants the rights to the two counties south of San Francisco -- San Mateo and Santa Clara. Magowan and his investment group purchased the Giants from Bob Lurie after the 1992 season, saving the team from a move to St. Petersburg, Fla.

It is Magowan's contention that the A's can build a stadium in numerous adjacent towns and communities in the East Bay that would not infringe on the Giants' territory. The A's have played in Network Associates Coliseum just south of Oakland since they moved from Kansas City in 1968. Oakland's Triple-A team plays in downtown Sacramento, the capital city of California, 90 miles to the northeast.

Magowan said each team holds its territorial rights more by tradition than by contract.

"If three-quarters of the clubs vote to put another stadium in San Francisco, there's nothing that the Giants can do to stop it," Magowan said. "There's nothing the Yankees could do about locating a third team across the street from Yankee Stadium. That aside, all the clubs know that if they start violating one team's territorial rights, their own territorial rights become almost valueless because a precedent has been set.

"So I think there's a very strong feeling that territorial rights should be upheld, because if we don't uphold them for this guy over here they might not be upheld for me."

Magowan, whose 11 years as an owner gives him seniority in the National League West, was selected to MLB's eight-owner executive council along with Peter Angelos of the Baltimore Orioles this past January. The pair replaced Carl Pohlad of the Minnesota Twins and Bill Bartholomay of the Atlanta Braves.

The executive council is the sounding board for Commissioner Bud Selig on all baseball-related matters.

Barry M. Bloom (barry.bloom@mlb.com) is a national reporter for MLB.com. This story is not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.

McCovey
01-15-2009, 10:06 AM
From a 2006 article.


A's Owner: Move To San Jose Unlikely

Thursday, August 31, 2006

Fremont Location Possible

Aug. 31 - BCN -- The co-owner of the Oakland Athletics baseball team told a meeting of the San Jose-Silicon Valley Chamber of Commerce Wednesday that the A's were unlikely to be relocating to downtown San Jose, according to a meeting attendee.

Santa Clara County Assessor Larry Stone said Wolff described several conversations he had with both Major League Baseball Commissioner Bud Selig, a former fraternity brother of Wolff's, and San Francisco Giants managing partner Peter Magowan about the territorial rights the Giants hold to Santa Clara County that are preventing an A's move south. Wolff offered, without success, to pay the Giants to allow the A's to move, according to Stone.

"The Commissioner was intractable. The Giants weren't interested," Stone said.

Wolff is now focusing on building a stadium for the A's in Fremont, near the Santa Clara County line. Stone believes when that happens the team will change its name to the San Jose Athletics and begin marketing itself to Silicon Valley residents and businesses.

"The Giants worst dream will come true. The A's will be marketing to Silicon Valley and San Jose and the Giants are not going to get a dime of compensation," Stone said.

A spokesman for San Jose Mayor Ron Gonzales said the mayor is "disappointed" about Wolff's remarks. Mayoral spokesman David Vossbrink said Gonzales believes Downtown San Jose remains the best place for the A's to play.

"San Jose really is an attractive market and it really would be in the best interests of baseball," Vossbrink said.

Bear
01-15-2009, 10:57 AM
We are not talking the Giants giving up anything. What's happening here is MLB is stripping the Giants of those rights and allowing the A's to move into the So. Bay market if they choose to. My guess is this is part of a deal the Giants had to make to avoid problems from the Steroid scandal. Wake up Mc. and smell the roses. The Giants will get no help from MLB and maybe have already given into the A's demands.:eek:

McCovey
01-15-2009, 11:06 AM
We are not talking the Giants giving up anything. What's happening here is MLB is stripping the Giants of those rights and allowing the A's to move into the So. Bay market if they choose to. My guess is this is part of a deal the Giants had to make to avoid problems from the Steroid scandal. Wake up Mc. and smell the roses. The Giants will get no help from MLB and maybe have already given into the A's demands.:eek:
Where in the article is there any mention of MLB taking the rights to Santa Clara County from the Giants? For years Bud Selig has been adamant about guaranteeing the Giants the South Bay. Selig hasn't budged on that stance one bit. According to the article Selif is still supporting a move to Fremont. Of course things may be different when Selig retires in a few years and a new commissioner comes in.

Bear
01-15-2009, 12:55 PM
We will just have to agree to disagree. If you can't read between the lines and see what is happening right in front of you so be it. The article at the top of the thread is there for all to read. I leave it up to the reader to take from it what they will.:bugeye:

McCovey
01-15-2009, 12:58 PM
We will just have to agree to disagree. If you can't read between the lines and see what is happening right in front of you so be it. The article at the top of the thread is there for all to read. I leave it up to the reader to take from it what they will.:bugeye:
Read between the lines? That how you "know" the A's are coming to San Jose? :p We shall see what happens.

McCovey
01-16-2009, 01:56 PM
If the A's were to move to Santa Clara where would their new ballpark be?

McCovey
02-24-2009, 03:07 PM
It's over! The A's are NOT moving to Fremont.


Statement by A's owner/managing partner Lew Wolff regarding attached letter sent to Fremont mayor & city council

02/24/2009 1:07 PM ET

Oakland Athletics Press Release

"After much consideration, today we informed Mayor Wasserman and City Council members that the Oakland Athletics will cease efforts to relocate our franchise to the City of Fremont. "I expressed my regrets and gratitude, especially to those people who shared our vision and spent endless hours in support of our proposal. However, it became increasingly clear that our ballpark project faced significant delays ahead and I could not, in good conscience, continue to lead our team down this path.

"My focus now is on baseball with Spring Training and the opening of the 2009 season. I am extremely excited about the team's prospects this year.

"My goal and desire for the organization is to determine a way to keep the team in Northern California. This goal has not changed."

McCovey
02-24-2009, 03:13 PM
From the San Jose Mercury News...

Oakland A's owner: Fremont is out

Matthew Artz

Bay Area News Group

Posted: 02/24/2009

The Oakland A's slammed the door on any move to Fremont today, citing strong opposition to both of their stadium proposals.

"I have concluded that further consideration of the A's relocating to Fremont must cease," team co-owner Lew Wolff wrote in a letter sent to city officials today.

Wolff's announcement has been expected since last week when he halted the environmental process needed for approve a future stadium either adjacent to the Pacific Commons shopping center west of Interstate 880, or between interstates 680 and 880 near the New United Motor Manufacturing Inc. plant.

The A's first targeted the Pacific Commons area south of Auto Mall Parkway, but ran into opposition from the center's three largest retailers, who feared the ballpark would cause traffic and parking problems.

The team then focused on a second site, about 1.5 miles to the southeast, adjacent to a planned BART station on the edge of the city's Warm Springs District. But that plan encountered stiff resistance from NUMMI, the city's largest employer, as well as from nearby residents, who threatened to file lawsuits to hold up stadium construction or put approval of the stadium to citywide vote.

The opposition was "such that the time and cost of having the application of the 'process' create further delays, legal actions and perhaps referendums is simply something that I have decided to forgo," Wolff wrote.

The team spent more than $80 million including real estate purchases in its effort to move to Fremont, Wolff wrote. He said $24 million of that cost is "not recoverable" and that the losses could increase if real estate values keep declining, he said.

Wolff said after the season opens, he will sit down with his son, Keith, A's President Mike Crowley, General Manager Billy Beane, his partners, and Cisco to "evaluate the next steps for the A's.